Home >> Application >> By Standard >> ASTM >> ASTM A-C >> ASTM C633 Thermal Spray Coating Adhesion Cohesion Testing

ASTM C633 Thermal Spray Coating Adhesion Cohesion Testing

Share:

ASTM C633 Thermal Spray Coating Adhesion Tester | UnitedTest

UnitedTest manufactures ASTM C633 compliant testing machines for thermal spray coatings. ASTM C633 measures coating adhesion bond strength to substrate or coating cohesion strength under normal tensile loading perpendicular to the coated surface.


ASTM C633 is the standard test method for measuring the adhesion or cohesion strength of thermal spray coatings. It evaluates the bond strength between the thermal sprayed coating and its substrate, or the internal cohesive strength of the coating itself, by applying tensile force normal and perpendicular to the coating surface. Widely used in aerospace, energy, automotive and marine coating quality control and material qualification. UnitedTest supplies robust ASTM C633 tensile test equipment for coating laboratories, coating manufacturers and third-party certification testing.


Test Principle:

A coating is sprayed onto the flat end face of a cylindrical substrate fixture; that coated face is then adhesively bonded to the face of an uncoated loading fixture; the resulting sandwich is pulled apart in uniaxial tension perpendicular to the coating plane until rupture. The reported strength is simply:

σ = Maximum tensile load / Cross-sectional (bonded) area

The physical meaning comes not from the equation but from where the crack went: interface fracture = adhesion strength; fracture inside the deposit = cohesion strength; fracture between two coating layers in a multilayer system = internal adhesive strength. Measured value always represents the weakest link of the assembly — coating, interface, or bonding agent.


Test Specimen Information

  • Geometry: two fixtures, each a circular solid cylinder ≥ 1.5 in. long; facing diameter 0.9–1.0 in. (23–25 mm); the two diameters must be identical and measured to within 0.5 % error; both end faces parallel to each other and normal to the load axis.

  • Substrate fixture material: preferably the actual metal intended for service; if unspecified, SAE 1018 or 1020 steel. A layer of the specified substrate material (>0.1 in. / 2.5 mm) may be bonded to a convenient metal body.

  • Loading fixture material: any metal; usually made identical to the substrate fixture so the two are interchangeable until one is coated.

  • Surface preparation: substrate face prepared per coating specification (grit blasting, surface grinding, etc.).

  • Coating thickness: measured with a micrometer (total length before vs. after spraying); final thickness > 0.015 in. (0.38 mm); if ground/machined, spray ~0.005 in. (0.13 mm) extra; thickness variation across the face ≤ 0.001 in. (0.025 mm) — otherwise respray or grind. No grit blasting of the coating surface after spraying.

  • Quantity: depends on purpose, but not fewer than five specimens per type for acceptance testing, plus one uncoated fixture pair bonded at the same time as an adhesive control.


Test Equipment of ASTM C633 Thermal Spray Coating Adhesion Cohesion Testing 

Tensile testing machine: 

Must satisfy ASTM E‑4 calibration requirements. Load accuracy tolerance ≤1.0 %.

It must record peak rupture load, and run constant cross‑head travel speed.

Constant cross-head travel rate between 0.030 in./min (0.013 mm/s) and 0.050 in./min (0.021 mm/s)

Self‑aligning fixture assembly

knurled / roughened surfaces to prevent slipping; grip dimensions minimum 1 × 1½ in (25.4 × 38 mm). 

Longer grip dimension runs perpendicular to pulling direction.

ASTM C633 Thermal Spray Coating Adhesion Cohesion Testing

Ancillary tooling

Micrometer (thickness), V-block or equivalent fixture for parallel alignment during cure, 

surface grinder with magnetic chuck, mechanical cleaning tools (grinding, light grit blast, emery cloth), 

and a low-power microscope up to 100× for failure-locus examination


Key Test Parameters and stipulations:

Cross‑head displacement rate: Constant travel speed between 0.030 in/min (0.013 mm/s) and 0.050 in/min (0.021 mm/s) throughout tension‑to‑failure.

Bonded area = fixture face area; strength reported in psi (or pascals).


Test Procedures of ASTM D2209 Test Method for Tensile Strength of Leather:

  1. Prepare the required number of substrate fixtures; prepare the substrate faces per specification.

  2. Thermally spray each fixture to the target thickness; grind/machine the coating face only if thickness variation is excessive.

  3. Clean the loading fixture faces (free of oil, grease, cutting fluids) by machining, grinding, light grit blasting or emery cloth.

  4. Prepare the adhesive; bond all loading fixtures to the coated faces at essentially the same time; wipe off excess adhesive.

  5. Hold the assembly parallel and aligned (e.g., in a V-block) until cured — not needed if the coating face was ground smooth.

  6. Simultaneously prepare one uncoated control pair to measure adhesive strength.

  7. Mount in the self-aligning grips and pull at a constant rate of 0.013–0.021 mm/s until rupture; record the maximum load.

  8. Compute σ = F_max / A for each specimen.

  9. Examine both fracture faces (microscope ≤100×) and classify the failure locus.

Failure classification: coating–substrate interface → adhesive; within the coating → cohesive; between bond coat and top coat → internal adhesive; in the bonding agent → acceptable for QC/qualification only if the agent's strength exceeds the minimum required coating strength (otherwise it is a lower bound, not a result); mixed-mode → generally no interpretation possible.


Industry / Application Fields

C633 is the default acceptance and quality-control method for thermal spray bond strength wherever a coating's survival depends on staying attached:

  • Aerospace / gas turbines — TBCs, abradables, clearance-control and hot-section repair coatings (e.g., HVOF/APS cobalt- and nickel-based deposits are routinely qualified with C633 bond-strength bands in the 30–70 MPa range).

  • Power generation and oil & gas — corrosion/oxidation barriers (thermal spray aluminum on steel pipe, per ASTM A1117), boiler and turbine components, pumps and valves.

  • Automotive — cylinder-bore, piston-ring and brake-disk coatings; remanufacturing and repair.

  • Industrial machinery / steel / printing / marine — wear-resistant WC-Co, CrC, and oxide coatings on rolls, shafts, and housings; corrosion protection of structures.

  • R&D and process development — ranking of spray parameters, substrate preparation, feedstock lot consistency, and operator/equipment qualification


Related & Similar Standards

ISO 14916Thermal spraying - Determination of tensile adhesive strength
EN 582Thermal spraying; determination of the tensile adhesive strength of thermally sprayed coatings
ASTM C633

Standard Test Method for Adhesion or Cohesion Strength of Thermal Spray Coatings

GB/T 8642Chinese national equivalent: Thermal spraying—Determinaton of tensile adhesive strength
JIS H 8402 Stated by JSA to be identical in content to ISO 14916
ASTM D4541Portable pull-off adhesion testers for paint/organic coatings — same "pull a dolly" principle.
ISO 4624Paints and varnishes - Pull-off test for adhesion
ASTM C297

Standard Test Method for Flatwise Tensile Strength of Sandwich Constructions

ASTM D897Standard Test Method for Tensile Properties of Adhesive Bonds
ASTM D2095

Standard Test Method for Tensile Strength of Adhesives by Means of Bar and Rod Specimens


Key differences ASTM C633 vs ISO 14916

ItemASTM C633ISO 14916:2017
Specimen formRod-type block onlyForm A block or Form B test disc (7 mm)
Diameter23–25.4 mm25 / 25.4 / 40 mm (25 mm preferred)
Length≥38.1 mm≥50 mm
Minimum coating thickness>380 µm>80 µm (foil adhesives allow thin coatings)
Specimens per set≥5≥3
Rate0.013–0.021 mm/s0.017 ± 0.004 mm/s (≈1 ± 0.24 mm/min)
AdhesivesNamed list (Annex A1)Not specified; foil adhesives recommended for porous coatings
Control specimenGlue-only pair tested with every setSame requirement


Why the Test Is Important for the Material

Thermal‑spray coatings rely on mechanical interlocking and limited metallurgical bonding to substrates. Insufficient adhesion or cohesion leads to spalling, delamination and premature component failure in service (wear, thermal cycling, corrosion environments).

  1. It provides a standardized comparative method to screen spray processes, feedstock powders, surface‑preparation methods and fixture materials.

  2. It qualifies coating batches for industrial acceptance, reducing risk of in‑service coating detachment.

  3. Fracture‑locus analysis identifies root causes: whether failure originates at substrate‑coating interface, within coating bulk or between multi‑coating layers, guiding process improvement.

  4. It supports material development for new thermal‑spray feedstock formulations.

  5. It enables supplier‑customer agreement on coating quality benchmarks, widely adopted under Nadcap, aerospace and energy‑sector specifications for thermal‑spray qualification work.


Keywords: ASTM C633,thermal spray coating adhesion test,coating cohesion strength tester,thermal spray bond strength test,normal tensile adhesion tester,thermal spray coating tensile test,coating substrate bond test,spray coating pull test machine,UnitedTest coating testing machine,thermal coating qualification test,metallic thermal spray coating test,ceramic thermal spray coating adhesion tester,surface coating tensile strength test,coating quality control tester,thermal sprayed coating lab test

Related products and device

ASTM C633 Thermal Spray Coating Adhesion Cohesion Testing Universal Testing Machine

WDW Series Computer Control Electronic Universal Testing Machine made by UNITEDTEST range from 100N to 600KN load capacity with various models like single columns, table type, door frame type etc., is used to perform tension, compression, flexure/bending, shearing, peeling etc., test for metal and nonmetal specimens.

ASTM C633 ADHESIVE BOND TENSILE FIXTURES

ASTM D897 ADHESIVE BOND TENSILE FIXTURES is designed and produced according the standard ASTM D897, it is a test method used to determine the comparative tensile strength of adhesive bonds, primarily between metal-to-metal substrates.

ASTM C633 coating substrate bond test fixture

Snubbing and Capstan grips are all engineered to perform high strength tensile tests where the test samples are long compared to their cross-sectional area, such as wire, rope and strapping.

Related Standard

ASTM D897 Tensile Test of Adhesive Bonds –

ASTM D897 prescribed a method for determining the comparative tensile properties of adhesive bonds in a standard specimen when tested under specific conditions. Its primary purpose was to measure the tensile strength of an adhesive bond between two rigid substrates (metal to metal). 

ASTM C297 Flatwise Tensile Strength Test of Sandwich Constructions –

ASTM C297 Standard Test Method for Flatwise Tensile Strength of Sandwich Constructions

ASTM C297 defines the test for measuring flatwise (through‑thickness) tensile strength of assembled sandwich panels. It quantifies the tensile strength of core material, core‑to‑facing adhesive bond, or facing skins when pulling normal to the panel plane. It covers continuous‑bond cores (foam, balsa wood) and discontinuous cellular cores (honeycomb).

EN 205 Wood adhesive lap joint shear test –

EN 205 specifies the test method used to assess adhesives for wood and derived timber products for non-structural applications, measuring the tensile shear strength of lap joints. This standard evaluates adhesive resistance to hot and cold water ageing and verifies bond strength with a thin bond line of approximately 0.1 mm. UnitedTest delivers reliable EN 205 wood adhesive testing instruments for adhesive formulation research, factory quality control and third-party laboratory certification.

ISO 16525-4 Isotropic Electrically Conductive Adhesive Shear & Electrical Resistance Test –

ISO 16525-4 Adhesives — Test methods for isotropic electrically conductive adhesives — Part 4: Determination of shear strength and electrical resistance using rigid-to-rigid bonded assemblies

ISO 16525-4 defines how to build a millimetre-scale ("miniature") bonded joint out of two rigid metal adherends and an isotropic conductive adhesive (ICA), then break it in shear while continuously measuring the joint's electrical resistance, so that mechanical strength and electrical continuity are evaluated on the same specimen at the same time.  UnitedTest  Test Machine

EN 14869-2 Thick Adherend Shear Test Systems for Structural Adhesives –

EN 14869‑2 Structural adhesives‑Determination of shear behaviour of structural bonds‑Part 2: Thick adherends shear test

EN 14869‑2 evaluates full shear stress‑strain performance of structural adhesives under tensile loading on single‑lap joints, minimising peel and secondary bending stress by utilising thick, rigid adherends and short overlap length, to approach pure‑shear stress state inside the adhesive layer.

ASTM D2294 Metal-to-Metal Adhesive Shear Creep Test –

ASTM D2294 Standard Test Method for Creep Properties of Adhesives in Shear by Tension Loading (Metal-to-Metal)

ASTM D2294 measures time‑dependent shear creep of a metal‑to‑metal adhesive joint. A standard lap‑type specimen is loaded in tension so that the adhesive bond sees essentially shear; once the target load is reached, a spring‑loaded creep apparatus holds the load statically while the specimen is held at a controlled temperature (and optionally humidity/environment). Creep deflection at the bondline is tracked versus time.

ISO 11003-1 Structural Adhesive Torsion Test by butt-bonded hollow cylinders –

ISO 11003‑1 Adhesives — Determination of shear behaviour of structural adhesives — Part 1: Torsion test method using butt‑bonded hollow cylinders

ISO 11003‑1 defines a torsion‑based shear test to characterise shear‑stress‑shear‑strain behaviour (including shear modulus, shear strength and failure strain) of structural adhesive bonds, delivering input data for advanced engineering design such as finite‑element analysis (FEA).   

ASTM D905 Wood Adhesive Compression Shear Test –

ASTM D905 Standard Test Method for Strength Properties of Adhesive Bonds in Shear by Compression Loading

ASTM D905 evaluates comparative shear strength of adhesive bonds, mainly wood-to-wood, using a compressed block/shear specimen. It comparative shear performance of laboratory‑prepared wood‑to‑wood adhesive joints under compressive force; it is intended for adhesive screening, R&D and process monitoring rather than direct design‑strength calculation for finished structural products.

Frequently Asked Questions (Q&A) for ASTM C633 Thermal‑Spray Coating Adhesion / Cohesion Test

Q1. What is ASTM C633?

ASTM C633 is the standard test method for determining the adhesion (bond) strength of a thermal spray coating to its substrate, or the cohesion strength of the coating itself, measured in tension normal (perpendicular) to the coating surface.


Q2. Which thermal spray processes and materials does it cover?

Processes: combustion flame, plasma arc (APS/VPS), two-wire arc, HVOF, and detonation gun, with feedstock as wire, rod or powder. Coating materials: metals, ceramics (oxides, carbides), cermets and multilayer systems. Substrates are normally metallic but may be ceramic (oxide, graphite).


Q3. What are the specimen dimensions?

Two matching circular solid cylinders, ≥ 1.5 in. (38.1 mm) long, with facing diameters of 0.9–1.0 in. (23–25 mm). The two diameters must be identical, measured to within 0.5 % error, and both end faces must be parallel to each other and normal to the loading axis. Recommended detail is given in Fig. 2 of the standard; Appendix X1 offers a cost-effective alternative "saddle + sample holder" load train.


Q4. What material are the fixtures made of?

The substrate fixture should preferably be the metal actually intended for service; if not specified, use SAE 1018 or 1020 steel. A layer of the real substrate material (>0.1 in. / 2.5 mm thick) may be bonded onto a cheaper fixture body. The loading fixture may be any metal; it is usually made identical to the substrate fixture so the pair is interchangeable until one is coated.


Q5. Why is there a minimum coating thickness of 0.38 mm (0.015 in.)?

Because thermal spray coatings are porous and the bonding adhesive can wick through the coating to the substrate, in which case the test measures the glue, not the coating. The 0.015 in. limit exists to prevent penetration. Porous ceramics and abradables are the highest-risk coatings; film adhesives (see Q11) or metallographic verification allow thinner deposits in practice under ISO 14916, but C633 as written still requires >0.38 mm.


Q6. Why must a glue-only control specimen be tested every time?

Because the adhesive is the measurement ceiling of the entire method — no strength above the adhesive's own strength can be measured. Bonding a loading fixture to a second loading fixture (no coating) at the same time detects bad two-part mixing, shelf-life degradation, or a wrong cure cycle. If the control fails below the required coating strength, prepare fresh adhesive and repeat.


Q7. Why is alignment so critical, and what equipment does that require?

The assembly is short, stiff and brittle with no compliance to absorb an off-axis pull. Any eccentricity converts part of the tension into bending, peels one edge of the coating plane and produces a premature, low failure load — appearing as unexplained scatter between nominally identical specimens. C633 therefore requires self-aligning load devices (often integral to the machine, or the arrangement of Fig. 1) at both ends, plus a V-block or equivalent holding device to keep the fixtures parallel and aligned during adhesive cure.


Q8. How does ASTM C633 differ from ISO 14916 / GB/T 8642?

Same physical principle, different detailing:

Item

ASTM C633

ISO 14916:2017 (GB/T 8642 MOD)

Specimen form

Rod/block only

Form A block or Form B test disc

Diameter

23–25.4 mm

25 / 25.4 / 40 mm (25 mm preferred)

Fixture length

≥ 38.1 mm

≥ 50 mm

Min. coating thickness

> 380 µm

> 80 µm (foil adhesives allow thin coatings)

Specimens

≥ 5

≥ 3

Rate

0.013–0.021 mm/s

0.017 ± 0.004 mm/s (≈ 1 ± 0.24 mm/min)

Adhesives

Named in Annex A1

Not specified; foil recommended for porous coatings

Machine calibration

ASTM E4

ISO 7500-1 (Class 1)

Other related standards: JIS H 8402 (≡ ISO 14916), EN 582 (withdrawn, replaced by EN ISO 14916), ASTM D4541 / ISO 4624 (portable pull-off for paints), ASTM C297, D897/D2095 (sandwich and butt-joint tension), ISO 13779-4 (hydroxyapatite implant coatings), plus supporting standards EN 13507 (pre-treatment), ISO 14917 (terminology), ISO 14924 (post-treatment), ASTM E1920 (metallographic preparation).


Q9. Which industries rely on it?

Aerospace and gas turbines (TBCs, abradables, hot-section repair), power generation and oil & gas (TSA corrosion barriers, boiler/turbine parts, pumps and valves), automotive (cylinder bores, brake discs, remanufacturing), steel, marine, printing and general machinery (HVOF WC-Co / CrC wear coatings), plus R&D, powder-lot release and operator/equipment qualification.


Q10. Why choose ASTM C633 Thermal Spray Coating Adhesion Cohesion Testing Machine from UnitedTest?

UnitedTest manufactures ASTM C633‑24 compliant testing machine for thermal spray coating adhesion and cohesion strength pull‑off test. Complete self‑aligning C633 fixture set, meets ASTM E‑4 calibration, for plasma spray, HVOF, arc‑spray coating quality control & Nadcap qualification.


UnitedTest is a professional manufacturer of material tensile testing machines and complete ASTM‑standard test fixtures. Our ASTM C633 testing system is fully compliant with ASTM C633‑24 “Standard Test Method for Adhesion or Cohesion Strength of Thermal Spray Coatings”, widely used to evaluate bond performance for plasma spray, HVOF, twin‑wire arc spray, flame spray and detonation‑spray coatings for aerospace, power‑generation turbine, oil‑gas, automotive and heavy‑equipment repair industries.

Our complete ASTM C633 test solution includes computer‑controlled universal tensile testing frame plus dedicated ASTM C633 self‑aligning fixture assembly, which eliminates eccentric load and bending moment strictly following standard drawing requirements. The system meets ASTM E‑4 force‑verification requirement with load accuracy better than 1 %, supports the specified cross‑head travel speed range of 0.030–0.050 in/min (0.013‑0.021 mm/s). It automatically captures maximum rupture load, calculates adhesion / cohesion strength, exports test reports with failure‑mode logging for thermal‑spray lab quality control, batch acceptance, operator qualification and new coating material R&D.


✅ Key features of UnitedTest ASTM C633 test kit:

  1. Complete self‑aligning jig set (saddle, sample holder, threaded loading fixtures, dowel pins), matching ASTM C633‑24 drawing dimensions, supports standard 1‑inch diameter test specimens. Optional alternative fixture geometry per Appendix X1 of ASTM C633.

  2. Tensile machine conforms to ASTM E‑4 calibration requirement; load tolerance less than 1.0 %.

  3. Constant low‑speed cross‑head control for slow tensile pull‑off to rupture.

  4. Computer software computes strength = max load / cross‑sectional area; stores test data, supports customizable test report templates for Nadcap, aerospace and supplier‑customer acceptance documentation.

  5. Compatible with metallic, cermet and ceramic thermal‑spray coatings (bond‑coats, thermal barrier coatings, wear‑resistant coatings).

  6. We supply full‑set technical guidance for specimen preparation, adhesive selection, test procedure and failure‑locus analysis for ASTM C633 pull‑off test.

Common applications: • Thermal‑spray coating batch quality‑control testing • Supplier acceptance qualification for thermal‑spray components • Qualification of spray process parameters & thermal‑spray operators • R&D comparison of coating powders, surface‑preparation processes • Compliance for Nadcap, aerospace and energy‑sector thermal‑spray specifications.

UnitedTest provides complete after‑sales service: machine installation, training, calibration support and spare fixture parts. Contact us to get quotation for ASTM C633 thermal‑spray coating adhesion testing machine.

< Previous: ASTM C473 Testing of Gypsum Panel Products (Flexural strength, Nail pull resistance

> Next: ASTM C719 Elastomeric Joint Sealant Adhesion/Cohesion Test (Hockman Cycle Test)

Require More Customized Solutions?

We offer customization to meet your specific needs. Our expert team will collaborate with you to develop the perfect product for you
Customize Now

Beijing United Test Co., Ltd.