Home >> Application >> By Standard >> ASTM >> ASTM E-F >> ASTM F2357 Abrasion Resistance Testing for Inks, Coatings & Membrane Switches

ASTM F2357 Abrasion Resistance Testing for Inks, Coatings & Membrane Switches

Share:

ASTM F2357 RCA Abrader Tester | Membrane Switch Ink Coating Abrasion Resistance - UnitedTest

UnitedTest manufactures ASTM F2357 RCA abrasion tester for accelerated wear testing of membrane switch inks and coatings. This Norman Tool RCA abrader measures cycles to wear limit and breakthrough for comparative abrasion ranking, ideal for graphic overlay quality control.


ASTM F2357 defines a comparative, accelerated abrasion test in which a strip of abrasive paper or polyester tape is drawn repeatedly across the printed or coated surface of a membrane switch under a specified normal load, and the surface is inspected at intervals until a defined visual failure point is reached. The result is reported as the number of cycles to "wear limit" and to "final breakthrough." It is explicitly a relative ranking tool — not a predictor of service life in finger-touches. UnitedTest supplies reliable ASTM F2357 RCA abrasion testing machines for membrane switch, graphic overlay and printed coating wear evaluation.


Test principle

  • A continuous, fresh abrasive medium (paper or polyester tape) moves across the specimen at a constant, controlled load. Because the tape is drawn from a supply reel to a take-up reel, each cycle presents new, uncontaminated abrasive to the surface — this eliminates debris build-up/cushioning error that plagues fixed-medium tests.

  • Abrasion progressively thins/removes the first-surface ink or coating. Visual inspection at intervals identifies two endpoints:

    • Wear limit = cycles until an underlying layer of a different color becomes visible through the first layer (not applicable to transparent coatings).

    • Final breakthrough = cycles until the first-surface ink/coating is completely removed.

  • Failure rule: on a first-surface printed line, final breakthrough constitutes failure regardless of the size of the damaged area — even a pinhole-sized break counts.


Test Specimen Information

  • Applicable materials: Printed or coated polyester, polycarbonate, silicone rubber and similar flexible substrates for membrane switches. Specimens can be flat or contoured (curved) samples.

  • Specimen requirements: Test area must have intact ink or coating. Contoured samples yield less repeatable results; non‑uniform rough surfaces bring extra result variation. Mounting must avoid specimen distortion during testing.


Test Equipment of ASTM F2357 Abrasion Resistance Testing for Inks, Coatings & Membrane Switches

Norman Tool RCA Abrader

Recommend UnitedTest RCA Paper Abrasion Tester. 

The primary instrument delivering continuous/cyclic abrasion under controlled loading. 

ASTM F2357 Abrasion Resistance Testing for Inks, Coatings

Specimen mounting fixture

Rigid holder securing specimens without bending or deflection, ensuring the test surface stays perpendicular to the force probe.


Abrasive media (from Norman Tool)

0.6875‑inch‑wide abrasive paper: for most general applications.

0.25‑inch‑wide polyester tape: recommended for concave surfaces and fine graphic patterns.


Auxiliary supplieslint‑free absorbent wipes, reagent‑grade n‑heptane or isopropyl alcohol for cleaning, soft brush or compressed air to clear loose wear debris.


Key test parameters: 

Applied force175 g (or otherwise specified between purchaser and seller)
Cleaning agentReagent-grade n-heptane or isopropyl alcohol, applied with a clean lint-free absorbent material, lightly wiped
DryingAir dry completely — minimum 2 hours
Endpoint criteriaCycles to wear limit (color show-through); cycles to final breakthrough (complete removal)
Inspection regimeInterrupt the instrument periodically at intervals to examine the specimen
Debris removalPeriodically remove loose abrading debris by light brushing or compressed air
Alignment cautionIf the test is stopped before the final endpoint, do not move the specimen — realigning the wear path is problematic


Test Procedures of ASTM F2357 Abrasion Resistance Testing for Inks, Coatings & Membrane Switches

  1. Mount specimen: Secure specimen firmly in the fixture; surface must be perpendicular to the force probe with zero distortion.

  2. Clean specimen surface: Wipe test area with lint‑free material moistened with n‑heptane or isopropyl alcohol. Allow surface to air‑dry for at least two hours. Inspect to confirm cleaning causes no visible surface damage.

  3. Inspect test region for ink/coating quality and surface residues.

  4. Install the required abrasive medium on the tester. Adjust the applied load to target value (default 175 g).

  5. Align the target test spot of specimen under the force probe. Gently lower the abrasive onto specimen surface and start abrasion cycles.

  6. Run abrasion either for pre‑set cycles or until visual failure criteria appear. Pause periodically to inspect for wear limit and final breakthrough. Even small‑area final breakthrough of surface printed lines counts as failure regardless of defect size.

  7. Remove loose wear debris intermittently by light brushing or compressed‑air blowing.

  8. After finishing the test, record all required data and document visual damage; photographs of test zone are recommended.


Similar test standard

ASTM F2357

Standard Test Method for Determining the Abrasion Resistance of Inks and Coatings on Membrane Switches Using the Norman Tool "RCA" Abrader

ASTM F3152Later RCA‑abrader‑based standard covering similar RCA abrasion testing for flexible‑interface coatings, following the same RCA‑abrader principle.
ASTM D4060

Taber‑abrader test for organic‑coating abrasion resistance; rotary‑wheel abrasion mechanism, different from RCA linear‑style abrasion; results cannot be directly cross‑compared.

ASTM D1044Taber‑abrader test for transparent‑plastic surface abrasion, using haze change as output metric, not visual breakthrough counting
ASTM G195Abrasion of transparent plastics and rotary-platform (Taber) wear testing guidance.
ISO 9352abrasion of plastics and coated fabrics; national paint-film abrasion methods.
ISO 5470-1Rubber- or plastics-coated fabrics - Determination of abrasion resistance - Part 1: Taber abrader
JIS L0849textile abrasion by the RCA method
ISO 8251

abrasion resistance of anodic oxidation coatings on aluminium (both use comparable RCA-style paper-tape principles).


Industry Application

Formally: quality control, R&D, evaluation of material combinations, and comparison of similar materials for membrane switches.

In practice, the RCA method is used well beyond membrane switches — it has become a de facto standard in the electronics, automotive, appliance, cell-phone, plastics and coatings industries, and on painted/plated organic finishes, foil, inked keypad lettering, and pad printing. Typical parts include:

  • Membrane switch panels and silicone/rubber keypads

  • Inked legends on appliance and treadmill control panels, TV remote controls, game controllers

  • Medical device panels, instrument overlays, decorative printed panels

  • Consumer electronics enclosures and keypad/lettering on phones, tablets, cameras, calculators, USB drives

  • Printed labels/barcodes, and coated surfaces on plastics and coatings generally.


Keywords: ASTM F2357, RCA abrader, Norman tool, RCA abrasion tester, membrane switch abrasion test, ink abrasion resistance, coating wear test, graphic overlay abrasion, polyester tape abrasion, abrasive paper wear test, membrane switch tester, printed surface durability, wear cycle test, breakthrough abrasion test, coating abrasion tester, membrane keypad testing, electronic graphic overlay test, UnitedTest abrasion machine, accelerated wear tester, surface friction test.

Related products and device

ASTM F2357 RCA Paper Abrasion Tester

Wheel rotary bending fatigue test machine is mainly used for rotating bending fatigue test of light alloy wheels of motorcycles and mopeds. Conform with standard ISO 8644-2006 Motorcycle- Light Alloy Wheels - Test Methods.

Related Standard

ASTM F3152 abrasion test for inks and coatings –

ASTM F3152 Standard Test Method for Determining Abrasion Resistance of Inks and Coatings on Substrates Using Dry or Wet Abrasive Medium

ASTM F3152 evaluating abrasion resistance of surface‑printed inks and coatings on substrates, supporting both dry‑abrasion and wet‑abrasion modes with optional chemical exposure.

ISO 3894 Commercial Vehicle Wheel Fatigue Testing –

ISO 3894 Road vehicles‑Wheels/rims for commercial vehicles‑Test methods

ISO 3894 defines two standardized laboratory fatigue test methods for disc wheels of commercial vehicles, buses, trailers and multi‑purpose passenger vehicles, to evaluate wheel fatigue strength under simulated road service conditions. Its purpose is to give wheel and vehicle manufacturers a uniform way to evaluate certain fatigue‑strength characteristics, so wheels from different suppliers/regions can be compared. 

ISO 3006 Test for Road vehicles Passenger car wheels for road use –

ISO 3006 Road vehicles — Passenger car wheels for road use — Test method

ISO 3006 defines two standardized laboratory fatigue test methods for passenger‑car road wheels, to assess wheel fatigue strength under simulated real‑driving cyclic loads. It contains two methods only: dynamic cornering fatigue and dynamic radial fatigue. 

ISO 3006 applies for passenger‑car wheels only, while ISO 3894 targets commercial‑vehicle (truck, bus, trailer) wheels.

ISO 10191 Passenger Car Tyre Test - Endurance, High-Speed, Bead unseating –

ISO 10191 Passenger car tyres — Verifying tyre capabilities — Laboratory test methods

ISO 10191 specifies laboratory test methods for verifying structural capability of passenger‑car pneumatic tyres, covering radial, diagonal / bias‑belted, and T‑type temporary‑use spare tyres. It includes five core test groups: endurance test, low‑pressure performance test (radial‑only), high‑speed test, strength test, bead‑unseating test (tubeless‑only).

FAQs for ASTM F2357 RCA Abrasion Test

Q1. What is ASTM F2357?

ASTM F2357 is an ASTM test method that describes how to subject inks and coatings on membrane switches to an abrasive medium under a specified force. A strip of abrasive paper (or polyester tape) is drawn repeatedly across the printed/coated surface under a controlled load, and the surface is inspected at intervals until a defined visual failure point is reached. The result is reported as the number of cycles to "wear limit" and to "final breakthrough."


Q2. What is an "RCA abrasion test"?

"RCA" refers to the Norman Tool RCA Abrasion Wear Tester, the instrument named in the standard. In the test, fresh abrasive paper tape feeds from a supply reel, contacts the specimen at the test point under a set load, and winds onto a take-up reel — so every cycle presents a clean, unused section of abrasive to the surface. This fresh-media design removes the debris build-up error common in fixed-medium abrasion tests.


Q3. What is the difference between "wear limit" and "final breakthrough"?

  • Wear limit = the number of cycles until an underlying layer of a different color can be seen through the first layer. (Not applicable to transparent coatings.)

  • Final breakthrough = the number of cycles until the first-surface ink or coating is completely removed.
    The standard adds a strict rule: on a first-surface printed line, final breakthrough is a failure regardless of the size of the damaged area — even a pinhole-sized break counts.


Q4. Is ASTM F2357 a pass/fail standard?

No. The standard itself does not set acceptance criteria. It is a comparative method that produces cycle counts. Pass/fail limits (for example "no breakthrough before 300 cycles at 175 g") are set by the purchaser, the supplier's specification, or an internal brand standard, and must always be stated alongside the test conditions.


Q5. Can the results predict how many finger touches a keypad will survive?

No — and the standard says so explicitly. F2357 provides no correlation value to the number of human finger touches before coating failure. It only allows comparison of results obtained with the same equipment, abrasive material and loading conditions.


Q6. What load (force) is used?

The standard specifies 175 g applied force, "or otherwise specified." Commercial RCA testers (including UnitedTest models) typically offer 55 g, 175 g and 275 g load settings, with 175 g the most widely specified in industry. The load actually used must be recorded in the report.


Q7. How must the specimen be cleaned before testing?

Wipe the test area with a clean, lint-free absorbent material moistened with reagent-grade n-heptane or isopropyl alcohol, then allow the surface to air dry completely (minimum two hours). Afterwards, inspect the test area to confirm the cleaning itself caused no visible damage. The cleaning method used must be reported.


Q8. What specimens can be tested?

Printed or coated polyester, polycarbonate and silicone rubber — and the method is not limited to these. Any material is acceptable provided the abrasion produces visible wear or breakthrough. Samples may be flat or contoured; however, contoured surfaces are harder to reproduce and some equipment is not designed for non-flat specimens. A smooth surface is preferred; rough or non-uniform surfaces require extra care and show greater specimen-to-specimen variation.


Q9. Can curved or concave parts (keypads, domes) be tested?

Yes, contoured surfaces can be tested, but the standard warns results may be more difficult to duplicate. For concave surfaces and fine graphic details, the narrower 0.25 in. (6.35 mm) polyester tape is recommended rather than the standard 0.6875 in. paper.


Q10. Why does the standard say "do not move the specimen" if the test is stopped early?

Because re-aligning the wear path is difficult. If the test is stopped before the final endpoint and the specimen is moved, the abrasion track cannot be reliably re-registered, and subsequent cycles will cut a different path — invalidating the result. Leave the specimen in place if you intend to resume.


Q11. What are typical acceptance criteria in industry?

These are commercial requirements, not part of the standard. Commonly seen values at 175 g include ≥ 100 cycles as a general entry-level requirement, ≥ 300 cycles for brand/high-end consumer electronics, and ≥ 500–1000 cycles for demanding coating applications such as phone/tablet housings, keyboards and automotive interior trim. Always confirm against the customer specification, and note whether "no breakthrough / no substrate exposure" or a gloss/appearance change is the governing criterion.


Q12. Why is ASTM F2357 important for inks and coatings?

Membrane switch keys are actuated repeatedly by a human finger and are also wiped, cleaned, rubbed, handled, shipped and stored. These actions can remove coatings, text and decorative inks. F2357 reproduces that wear in a controlled, accelerated, repeatable way and converts it into a single comparable number.


Q13. Why does it matter specifically for printed legends and keypads?

Because legibility is function, not decoration. On a keypad, control panel or medical device overlay, the printed legend is the user interface. Once the ink breaks through, the product is mislabeled, non-intuitive or unsafe — which is why the standard treats any breakthrough on a first-surface printed line as failure regardless of size.


Q14. How does RCA differ from Taber abrasion (ASTM D4060)?

Taber uses two weighted abrasive wheels rotating against a flat specimen in a circular path, with a much larger contact area, and reports mass loss or Wear Index (mg/1000 cycles). RCA uses a narrow strip of paper tape with a small, focused contact that better replicates fingertip-scale wear on small printed features, and reports cycles to a visual endpoint. They rank materials differently — choose the method that matches the real service condition. Note D4060 is similar in content but not technically equivalent to ISO 7784-2.


Q15. How does RCA differ from cross-cut adhesion (ASTM D3359 / ISO 2409)?

They measure different failure axes. Cross-cut evaluates adhesion (bond strength, graded 0B–5B); RCA evaluates abrasion/wear resistance (cycles to breakthrough). A coating can pass cross-cut and still fail RCA, so both are usually specified together in a coating durability program.


Q16. Which industries use ASTM F2357?

Formally, membrane switch manufacturers. In practice it is a de facto standard across consumer electronics, automotive, appliances, mobile phones, plastics, product labels and industrial coatings — used on painted or plated organic finishes, foil, inked keypad lettering and pad printing. Typical parts: membrane switch panels, silicone/rubber keypads, appliance and treadmill control panels, TV remotes, game controllers, medical device panels, instrument overlays, decorated printed panels, printed labels and barcodes.


Q17. Why choose UnitedTest RCA Abrasion Tester for ASTM F2357 Test? 

UnitedTest is professional manufacturer of RCA Abrasion Tester meeting ASTM F2357‑10 standard. Test abrasion resistance for membrane switches, flexible keypads, printed inks and coatings on polyester, polycarbonate and silicone rubber substrates. Support 175 g standard load, flat & contoured specimen testing, for lab R&D and factory quality control.


UnitedTest is trusted manufacturer of RCA Abrasion Tester for membrane‑switch abrasion resistance testing following ASTM F2357‑10 standard method.

Our RCA abrasion test machine simulates real‑world surface wear caused by repeated finger actuation, wiping and cleaning for membrane switches, flexible keypads, graphic overlay inks and surface coatings. It measures two critical failure metrics defined in ASTM F2357‑10: wear limit and final breakthrough cycles.

✅ Standard Compliance: Built for ASTM F2357‑10 requirements, compatible with ASTM F3152‑16 successor standard. 

✅ Standard Load: Default 175 g applied load; custom weight configuration available. 

✅ Two abrasive media options: Support 0.6875‑inch abrasive paper for general use, and 0.25‑inch polyester tape for concave samples and fine graphic details. 

✅ Specimen compatibility: Test flat and contoured samples for polyester, polycarbonate, silicone‑rubber printed membrane‑switch substrates. 

✅ Reliable fixture system: Rigid sample holder prevents specimen deflection to ensure repeatable test results. 

✅ Application scenarios: R&D material comparison, incoming‑material quality control, supplier evaluation for membrane‑switch, flexible‑printed‑electronics industries.


UnitedTest RCA Abrasion Tester helps engineers rank ink and coating performance, verify cosmetic durability and reduce product failure risk for membrane‑switch human‑machine‑interface products.

< Previous: ASTM F2118 Bone Cement Fatigue Test

> Next: ASTM F2477 Test for in-vitro Pulsatile Durability Testing of Vascular Stents

Require More Customized Solutions?

We offer customization to meet your specific needs. Our expert team will collaborate with you to develop the perfect product for you
Customize Now

Beijing United Test Co., Ltd.